Opinions

Iceland’s Dysfunctional Political And Social Systems

 
Photo: RÚV / Ragnar Visage

The Teachers' Union of Iceland has been acquitted by the Labour Court of claims that the teachers' strike announcement was unlawful. Strikes will therefore commence in 11 schools next week if an agreement is not reached.

The Teachers' Union of Iceland was acquitted this morning of claims that the announced teachers' strikes were called in an unlawful manner.

Iceland, hosting the 2024 Nordic Council in Reykjavik from 28 to 31 October, under an interim government and facing a wave of public sector strikes, is a compelling example of the ultimate failure of the Nordic social model, which has been slowly deteriorating since the collapse of the Soviet Union.

The Icelandic people's dissatisfaction with their socio-economic situation, caused by the failed policies of the coalition government, has led to a wave of  public sector strikes, which could begin today, 29 October, with a strike by teachers, followed by a strike by health workers. Growing social inequality in the sparsely populated Scandinavian country has become the main reason for the country's unusually high record of intentional homicides, including  the elderly and minors.

Teachers demand basic monthly salaries of over 1 million ISK which equals 6,722.05 EUR.

Magnús Þór Jónsson, chairman of the Teachers' Union of Iceland, states that strikes will go ahead in 11 schools next week (years 44th week) if an agreement is not reached before then.

Magnús explains that a considerable amount of time has been spent preparing the case for the Labour Court, which has left less time available for negotiations. However, now that a decision has been made, the negotiating committees can sit down and continue working on reaching a collective bargaining agreement for teachers.

Magnús says that there is now not much time left for negotiations before the strikes are set to begin on Tuesday.

"It is clear that the strikes will take place on Tuesday if we do not manage to complete the task by then," says Magnús.

According to Magnús, it is clear what needs to happen for a collective agreement to be reached.

"We want investment in teachers. This will result in increased professionalism and stability in our systems. And this needs to happen with reference to the 2016 agreement that stipulates wage equalisation. That is what needs to happen for us to cancel the strike," says Magnús.

The head of the municipalities' negotiation committee says it's unlikely an agreement will be reached in the negotiations between teachers, municipalities, and the state before Tuesday.

Teachers are demanding salaries of over one million ISK per month, in line with the average salaries of professionals in the public sector. Inga Rún Ólafsdóttir, head of the municipalities' negotiation committee, told Rás 2 that it is difficult to meet this demand, as the rights of public sector employees differ from those of employees in the private sector.

Inga Rún Ólafsdóttir. Photo: RÚV / Ragnar Visage

Public sector employees have far greater rights than those in the private sector; they are entitled to much more sick leave, longer holiday entitlement, and teachers have much more control over their working hours than professionals in the private sector. If we accept this million-demand, then you also take [away] everything else that accompanies a professional in the private sector. So the summer holiday is shortened, the winter holiday is eliminated, the Christmas holiday is eliminated, the Easter holiday is eliminated, and the continuous education [lifelong learning] period, which is in the third week every year, paid, would have to be eliminated, because professionals in the private sector do not have this.

She says it is time to reconsider teachers' working hours and work arrangements.

"Teaching and the work of teachers are extremely important and also very demanding," says Inga Rún. She points out that teachers' working obligations are compressed into nine and a half months of the year.

"And we would all understand that if we intended to compress an entire year's work into nine and a half months, it would be extremely difficult. So, this is something that we see calls for a review."

She mentions as an example various other tasks besides direct teaching that could be carried out differently.

"We are extremely concerned about the working environment of teachers and the pressure they are under."

"Disputes with teachers are always somewhat difficult, and people take to heart everything that is said, and are perhaps a bit sensitive to what is said,"
says Inga Rún, citing a recent statement from the Icelandic Chamber of Commerce. "And, of course, it is not the holy truth, but it perhaps gives certain indications that there are opportunities for improvements, and people should not take it as an attack on teachers."

Asked whether these are suitable messages to send ahead of the negotiation meeting, Inga Rún said: "We need to talk through the issues, and it is not meant in a bad way at all."

Strikes will begin in nine schools on 29 October, in a tenth school on 11 November, and in an eleventh on 25 November.

Nearly one thousand doctors working in hospitals and health centres employed by the state could also go on strike on 18 November if negotiations fail.

Steinunn Þórðardóttir. Photo: RÚV – Stefán Jón Ingvarsson

Doctors are planning to commence strike action on 18 November if no agreement is reached in collective bargaining with the state. A vote on the matter is set to take place over the weekend.

The dispute involves nearly one thousand doctors employed by the state, working in hospitals and health centres alike. Negotiations continue with the State Mediator today.

Steinunn Þórðardóttir, chair of the Icelandic Medical Association, states that there is still active dialogue, though there is significant discontent among grassroots doctors.

We have not received the shortening of the working week that other healthcare professions have long enjoyed. The base salary is significantly lower than that of other university-educated professions, to name just one issue.

When asked, Steinunn said that it will become clear in the coming days whether there is a basis for an agreement. "There is always hope that we can reach a consensus before any action is taken, and that is naturally what we wish for."

"Something is happening in Icelandic society"

Margrét Valdimarsdóttir – Photo: RÚV — Guðmundur Bergkvist

Even though 2024 is not over yet, Iceland has set an all-time record for intentional murders in the nation's history: mothers and fathers killed their young children, and an elderly couple died at the hands of killers. See the martyrology.

Margrét Valdimarsdóttir, criminologist, says that never before have there been as many homicides committed in a single year.

"It is unprecedented in Icelandic history for eight individuals to be murdered in the same year," she says.

She notes that for a long time, the increase in the frequency of homicides was in line with population growth.

"But what we are seeing this year, and what we have been seeing in recent years, is more than just population growth. So, something seems to be happening in Icelandic society that is pushing this kind of serious violence."

Research shows, for example, that increased social inequality leads to more violence.

"And when social connections weaken, and when people do not receive appropriate help for addiction or mental health problems, when that number increases – and when organised crime increases – then the frequency of homicides rises," says Margrét.

There are indications that all these factors have become more prevalent in this country. Margrét says it is important to respond.

"For example, by improving access to mental health services. I think that is very important, and I also think that policing matters. We must not underestimate the significance of strong, effective policing."

The North Observer

29.10.2024